I decided to try out one of their many Panini's as opposed to their highly publicized tapas. I chose the Italiano which consisted of parma ham, soppressato, pepperoni, mozzarella, arugula and balsamic grilled sourdough bread. Presented alongside a a mixed leaf salad I took one bite of my panini and immediately had wished that I had just ordered the salad. The Panini, was only lightly pressed and the bread was so thick that it was hard to enjoy the fillings. The fillings were great together but because it was a light offering I mostly ate bread. I was very disappointed. I ended up only eating half of the sandwich. After the meal, I ordered a cappuccino and to my dismay it arrived lukewarm. It seemed as though the afternoon simply could not be salvaged.
The only thing going for Fat Fish is the view. The food, doesn't stand out and is over priced for the quality. I wish I could get my money back but oh well. Of course I intend to go back, I am as one might surmise a glutton for punishment. Not too mention, there are only a few restaurants actually on the water along the South Shore of Long Island. Maybe after my next visit, I'll make an amendment to this and highlight some good dishes.